Docker-compose: node_modules not present in a volume after npm install succeeds

ONLINECAST

3 min read

·

06-09-2024

20

0

Share

Docker-Compose and Missing node_modules: A Case Study in Volume Management

Docker-Compose is a powerful tool for managing multi-container applications. However, sometimes you might encounter unexpected behaviors, like the disappearance of node_modules after a successful npm install within a Docker container.

This article will delve into a real-world scenario, analyzing a common problem and presenting solutions based on Stack Overflow discussions.

The Problem: Missing node_modules

Let's revisit the scenario outlined in the Stack Overflow question.

We have a worker service that utilizes npm install to fetch dependencies. While the installation appears successful within the container's build process, the node_modules directory is mysteriously absent when the container is running.

This is a classic case of volume management misconfiguration, which can lead to a frustrating "dependency-not-found" error, as highlighted in the provided Stack Overflow question.

Analyzing the Cause: Volume Order and Build-Time vs. Run-Time

The issue stems from the order of operations and the way Docker volumes interact with the build process:

• Build-Time: The docker-compose build command builds the worker image. During this phase, npm install runs successfully within the container, creating node_modules inside the image.
• Run-Time: When docker-compose up is executed, the worker container starts. The volume mapping (worker/:/worker/) is applied after the container image is created.

The problem lies in the fact that volumes overwrite existing content.

Since the worker directory on the host is empty, it overwrites the content of the container's /worker directory, including the node_modules folder that was created during the build process. This leads to the "Cannot find module" error.

Solutions:

The key to fixing this is to ensure that the node_modules folder is either:

1. Created within the host's worker directory before docker-compose up
2. Persistent within the container itself.

Here are a few effective solutions, inspired by the Stack Overflow question and community responses:

• Solution 1: Host-Based Installation

  As suggested in the original Stack Overflow question, running npm install directly on the host's worker directory before starting the container will ensure that the node_modules are present when the volume is mounted.

  • Advantages: Simple and straightforward.
  • Disadvantages: May not be suitable for automated workflows or deployments where pre-installation on the host is not feasible.

• Solution 2: Volume Mounting with Persistent node_modules

  Instead of relying on the host's directory, we can mount a named volume to persist node_modules within the container.

  Modified docker-compose.yml:

  volumes:
    node_modules:
  redis:
    image: redis
  worker:
    build: ./worker
    command: npm start
    ports:
      - "9730:9730"
    volumes:
      - node_modules:/worker/node_modules
      - worker/:/worker/
    links:
      - redis
  

  Modified worker/Dockerfile:

  FROM node:0.12
  
  WORKDIR /worker
  
  COPY package.json /worker/
  
  RUN npm install
  
  COPY . /worker/
  

  • Advantages: Maintains container isolation while ensuring persistent node_modules.
  • Disadvantages: Requires adjusting Docker Compose configuration.

• Solution 3: Using a Multi-Stage Build

  A more elegant and efficient solution involves using multi-stage builds, which allow us to separate the build and runtime phases:

  Modified worker/Dockerfile:

  # Build stage
  FROM node:0.12 as builder
  WORKDIR /app
  COPY package*.json ./
  RUN npm install
  COPY . .
  
  # Runtime stage
  FROM node:0.12
  WORKDIR /app
  COPY --from=builder /app/node_modules ./node_modules
  COPY --from=builder /app/ . 
  CMD ["npm", "start"]
  

  • Advantages: Eliminates the need for external volume mounting and ensures clean container images.
  • Disadvantages: Requires understanding multi-stage builds and may increase complexity for beginner Docker users.

Conclusion:

The "missing node_modules" problem in Docker-Compose is a common scenario, arising from the interplay between volume mounting, build processes, and the order of container startup.

The provided solutions offer different approaches to address the issue, each with its own advantages and drawbacks. By understanding the cause and applying the appropriate solution, you can ensure that your dependencies are properly managed and your Docker containers function as intended.

Remember to consult the Docker Compose documentation and the Stack Overflow community for further insights and potential solutions.