How to make one of two parameters mandatory, so that at least one of the two is always present?

2 min read 21-09-2024
How to make one of two parameters mandatory, so that at least one of the two is always present?


In many programming scenarios, there are situations where you want to enforce that at least one of two parameters must be provided. This requirement often arises in API design or function definitions, where it's essential to ensure that the function receives enough information to proceed with its operations. Here, we will illustrate how to implement this functionality with an example and an explanation.

Problem Scenario

Let's say we have a function that accepts two parameters: param1 and param2. The requirement is that at least one of these parameters must be provided when calling the function. If neither parameter is supplied, the function should raise an error.

Here is a simple implementation that does not meet our requirement:

def my_function(param1=None, param2=None):
    if param1 is None and param2 is None:
        raise ValueError("At least one of param1 or param2 must be provided")
    # Function logic goes here

While the above code does check for the absence of both parameters, it might not be clear at first glance. Let's improve upon this example and make it more user-friendly and flexible.

Enhanced Implementation

To achieve the requirement of making at least one of the parameters mandatory, we can employ a more structured approach. Here’s how you can modify the function to enforce that rule while ensuring it remains easy to understand.

def my_function(param1=None, param2=None):
    if not (param1 or param2):
        raise ValueError("At least one of the parameters 'param1' or 'param2' must be provided")
    print("Function executed successfully with:", param1, param2)

# Example calls
my_function(param1="Hello")
my_function(param2="World")
my_function(param1="Hello", param2="World")
# my_function()  # Uncommenting this will raise an error

Explanation

  1. Parameter Validation: The if not (param1 or param2): condition checks if both parameters are either None or falsy values. If that’s the case, it raises a ValueError with a clear message, indicating which parameters are required.

  2. Versatile Output: When the function is called with at least one of the parameters, it executes successfully, printing the provided parameters.

Practical Example

Imagine you're designing an API for a messaging application where users can send either a text message or a voice note. You might want to implement a function that ensures a message type is always provided.

def send_message(text=None, voice_note=None):
    if not (text or voice_note):
        raise ValueError("You must provide either a text message or a voice note")
    
    if text:
        print(f"Sending text: {text}")
    if voice_note:
        print(f"Sending voice note: {voice_note}")

# Example usage
send_message(text="Hello there!")
send_message(voice_note="This is a voice message.")
# send_message()  # This will raise an error

Conclusion

By effectively managing parameters in your functions and enforcing at least one mandatory parameter, you create more robust and user-friendly APIs or functions. This approach helps in reducing errors and enhances the developer experience.

Useful Resources

Implementing such validations not only improves your code quality but also makes it more maintainable and easier to use.