If I use Map.get('key1') in angular template, does the change detection mechanism check the map value every cycle?

ONLINECAST

2 min read

·

30-08-2024

15

0

Share

Angular Change Detection and Maps: Do They Get Checked Every Time?

When working with Angular templates, it's crucial to understand how change detection works to prevent unnecessary performance overhead. One common question is: Does Angular check the value of a Map every change detection cycle when accessed via Map.get('key1') in a template?

The short answer is yes, Angular will re-evaluate myMap.get('key1') during each change detection cycle. This is because Angular's change detection mechanism doesn't have specific knowledge about how maps work internally. It treats the expression as a function that might potentially return a different value each time.

Why This Matters:

• Performance Impact: Frequent map lookups can lead to performance issues if the map is large or frequently updated.
• Unnecessary Re-rendering: The template might re-render unnecessarily if the map value doesn't actually change, leading to a suboptimal user experience.

Addressing the Issue:

1. Caching the Value: One approach is to cache the result of myMap.get('key1') in a component variable. This way, Angular will only re-evaluate the expression if the cached variable changes.

   import { Component, OnInit } from '@angular/core';
   
   @Component({
     // ...
   })
   export class MyComponent implements OnInit {
     myMap = new Map();
     key1Value: any; // Cached value
   
     ngOnInit() {
       this.key1Value = this.myMap.get('key1');
     }
   }
   

   <ng-container *ngIf="key1Value">...</ng-container> 
   

2. Using the async Pipe: If the map's value is asynchronous (e.g., coming from an API call), the async pipe can handle subscriptions and updates automatically.

   // ... (same component as above)
   key1Value$ = this.myMap.get('key1'); // Observable
   
   ngOnInit() {
     // ...
   }
   

   <ng-container *ngIf="(key1Value$ | async) as value">
     <!-- Use value here -->
   </ng-container>
   

3. Change Detection Strategies: For complex scenarios, you can explore Angular's change detection strategies like ChangeDetectionStrategy.OnPush. This approach requires you to explicitly trigger change detection when the map value is updated.

Testing the Behavior:

You can test this behavior by creating a simple component that uses Map.get('key1') in its template.

1. Observe the console logs: Add console.log() statements within the component's ngOnInit, ngDoCheck, and ngOnChanges lifecycle hooks. This will reveal how often these methods are executed.
2. Manually trigger change detection: Use the ChangeDetectorRef.detectChanges() method to force change detection and observe the output.
3. Compare the execution count: Compare the number of times console.log() is executed when the map value changes versus when it doesn't change.

Conclusion:

While using Map.get('key1') directly in a template is convenient, it comes with the performance cost of re-evaluation during each change detection cycle. By understanding the potential impact and applying techniques like caching or utilizing the async pipe, you can optimize your Angular applications for better performance and user experience.

Remember to always prioritize clear code and efficient performance in your Angular applications!

Credits:

• Stack Overflow Question: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/68702871/if-i-use-map-getkey1-in-angular-template-does-the-change-detection-mechanism-check-the-map-value-every-cycle