Where should I put uploaded files on a Clean Architecture project?

ONLINECAST

2 min read

·

05-10-2024

10

0

Share

File Storage in Clean Architecture: Navigating the Layers

Clean Architecture, with its emphasis on separation of concerns, provides a robust framework for building maintainable and scalable applications. However, when it comes to handling uploaded files, developers often face the question: where do these files belong in the layered structure?

Understanding the Problem

The challenge lies in reconciling the physical nature of uploaded files with the principle of separating business logic from infrastructure concerns. Simply placing files directly in the domain layer (where business logic resides) violates the clean architecture principles and creates tight coupling between the application and the file storage mechanism.

Scenario and Original Code

Let's imagine a simple e-commerce application built using Clean Architecture. A user uploads a product image, and the application needs to store it for later retrieval.

Naive Approach:

// Domain Layer - Product.java
public class Product {
    private String name;
    private String imageUrl; // Direct file path 

    // ... other methods
}

// Infrastructure Layer - FileStorageService.java
public class FileStorageService {
    public void saveImage(String imageUrl, byte[] imageData) {
        // Directly writes the image data to the file system
    }
}

This approach has several drawbacks:

• Tight Coupling: The Product entity is directly tied to the file storage mechanism, making it difficult to switch to different storage solutions (like cloud storage).
• Domain Logic Contamination: The imageUrl attribute in the Product entity is a path on the file system, not a business-related property.
• Testability Issues: Unit testing becomes difficult as it involves interacting with the file system.

Clean Architecture Solution

The solution lies in adopting a File Repository pattern. Here's a breakdown:

1. File Repository:

   • A dedicated interface in the domain layer (e.g., FileRepository) defines methods for interacting with files: saveFile, getFile, deleteFile, etc.
   • This interface acts as a contract between the domain and infrastructure layers.

2. Infrastructure Layer:

   • Implements the FileRepository interface using concrete implementations (e.g., FileSystemFileRepository, CloudStorageFileRepository).
   • These implementations handle the actual file storage mechanism.

Example Implementation

// Domain Layer - FileRepository.java
public interface FileRepository {
    String saveFile(String fileName, byte[] fileData);
    byte[] getFile(String fileName);
    void deleteFile(String fileName);
}

// Domain Layer - Product.java
public class Product {
    private String name;
    private String fileId; // Unique identifier for the file

    // ... other methods
}

// Infrastructure Layer - FileSystemFileRepository.java
public class FileSystemFileRepository implements FileRepository {
    private String storageDirectory;

    @Override
    public String saveFile(String fileName, byte[] fileData) {
        // Save file to the configured storage directory
        // Return a unique file identifier (e.g., file name)
    }

    // ... implementations for getFile and deleteFile
}

Benefits of this Approach

• Decoupling: The domain layer remains oblivious to the underlying file storage mechanism, making it easier to switch storage solutions.
• Testability: You can easily mock the FileRepository interface during unit testing, allowing you to focus solely on testing the domain logic.
• Separation of Concerns: The responsibility of file storage is delegated to the infrastructure layer, keeping the domain layer clean and focused on business logic.

Additional Considerations

• File Naming and Organization: Implement robust strategies for generating unique file identifiers and organizing files within your storage system.
• Security: Employ appropriate security measures to protect uploaded files from unauthorized access.
• Error Handling: Handle file upload and retrieval errors gracefully.

Conclusion

By embracing the File Repository pattern, you can seamlessly integrate file handling into your Clean Architecture project, maintaining a clean separation of concerns, improving testability, and allowing for easy customization of your file storage solutions.