Why ViewChild doesn't work with attr.id in angular8+?

ONLINECAST

2 min read

·

06-10-2024

7

0

Share

Understanding ViewChild and Its Quirks: Why It Doesn't Work with attr.id in Angular 8+

Angular's ViewChild decorator provides a powerful way to interact with child components or elements within a parent component's template. However, you might encounter unexpected behavior when using ViewChild with elements that are identified solely by their attr.id. This article delves into the reasons behind this behavior and offers effective alternatives for accessing elements based on their ID in Angular 8+.

The Scenario:

Imagine you have a simple component with a button element:

<button attr.id="myButton">Click Me!</button>

You want to access this button element from the parent component using ViewChild. Your parent component code might look like this:

import { Component, ViewChild, ElementRef } from '@angular/core';

@Component({
  selector: 'app-parent',
  template: `
    <app-child></app-child>
  `
})
export class ParentComponent {
  @ViewChild('myButton') myButton: ElementRef;

  onClick() {
    // Access the button element using myButton
    console.log(this.myButton);
  }
}

However, in Angular 8+, this code will not work as expected. this.myButton will be undefined even though the button element exists in the DOM.

The Reason: ViewChild and Dynamic ID Generation

The core issue lies in how Angular handles element IDs and the ViewChild decorator. Angular, by default, generates unique IDs for elements within your component template. This is a crucial part of its change detection and rendering mechanism.

When you use attr.id to set an ID, Angular does not treat it as a standard, dynamically generated ID. Instead, it treats it as a static attribute. This means that ViewChild cannot reliably locate the element using the ID specified in attr.id.

Solutions and Alternatives:

1. Use a Template Reference Variable: The most straightforward and recommended solution is to use a template reference variable:

   <button #myButton>Click Me!</button>
   

   This approach directly binds the button element to a variable named myButton in your component, allowing you to access it easily:

   @ViewChild('myButton') myButton: ElementRef;
   

2. Use a Directive with @ViewChild: If you need more flexibility or want to reuse the logic for accessing elements based on ID, you can create a directive:

   @Directive({
     selector: '[appFindById]'
   })
   export class FindByIdDirective {
     constructor(private elementRef: ElementRef) {}
   }
   
   // In your parent component:
   @ViewChild('myButton', { read: FindByIdDirective }) myButton: FindByIdDirective;
   

   The directive allows you to easily access the element using this.myButton.elementRef.

3. Querying by Element Type: If you need to access multiple elements of a specific type, you can use @ViewChildren and query by element type:

   @ViewChildren('button') buttons: QueryList<ElementRef>;
   

Important Considerations:

• Avoid using attr.id for dynamic ID generation: As demonstrated, using attr.id can cause compatibility issues with Angular's internal ID management.
• Prioritize Template Reference Variables: They offer the most straightforward and reliable approach for accessing specific elements within your templates.

Conclusion:

Understanding the relationship between ViewChild and Angular's ID management is crucial for avoiding common pitfalls. While ViewChild provides a powerful tool for interacting with child elements, it's essential to choose the appropriate method based on the specific scenario. By using template reference variables or directives, you can ensure reliable access to elements within your Angular components.